Citizenship Question on 2020 Census


Judge Enjoins Department of Commerce

The Department of Commerce has been enjoined by a federal judge from including the citizenship question in the upcoming Census.

The case began on March 26, 2018, when Secretary of Commerce Wilbur L. Ross, Jr., announced that he would reinstate a citizenship question in the Decennial 2020 Census. In 1960, out of a fear that the question would depress the count for already “hard to count” groups, the Census stopped including the citizenship question in the general census.

Plaintiffs in 18 states, the District of Columbia, 15 cities and counties, the U.S. Conference of Mayors and a group of NGOs filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, challenging the reinstatement of the citizenship question.

After a bench trial, U.S. District Court Judge Jesse M. Furman issued an opinion in New York, et al. v. U.S. Department of Commerce, No. 18-cv-2921 (Jan. 15, 2019), finding that Secretary Ross had violated the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) in certain ways, including 1) the decision was arbitrary and capricious; 2) the Secretary had failed to notify Congress as required by the APA; and 3) the Secretary’s reason for instituting the question, in order to enforce the Voting Rights Act of 1965, was pretextual (although the Court did not specifically find that the reason was a pretext for discrimination). Judge Furman vacated the Secretary’s decision and enjoined the Department of Commerce from including the citizenship question in the Census unless and until the legal defects are cured.

Judge Furman’s opinion is extensive (277 pages). In the opinion, he detailed the history of the Census, expressed his concern over the government’s strenuous efforts to stop the litigation, and addressed all of the issues presented. He acknowledged the opinion was quite long, but explained that he wants to be sure there is an extensive record given the certainty of an appeal.

We will continue to follow this case as it progresses through the appeal process. The length of this process could in and of itself prevent the citizenship question from being included in the 2020 Census.

Answer questions by getting a Free Consultation

Leave a message or call for a consultation. I'm here to answer.

How to Become a Dual Citizen of the USA

Applying for Dual Citizenship Processing immigrant visas, go...

Adjustments of Status Through VAWA

What is the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)? VAWA is a sig...

Understanding the Green Card Renewal Process

How to Renew Your Green Card A green card is officially kn...
Main Office Address

Diener Law Abogados

2000 Avondale Drive Suite W
Suite 400A
Durham, NC 27704
United States

Consult a certified attorney

Which Immigration concern can we help you with? I need to...

Copyright © 2021 Diener Law Abogados.  All Rights Reserved. | Powered by Advantage Attorney Marketing & Cloud Solutions

LA VERDAD SOBRE LOS INMIGRANTES Y LA LEY

truth about immigrants and the law

Lecciones aprendidas ayudando a más de 50,000 inmigrantes en todo el país.

LA VERDAD SOBRE LOS INMIGRANTES Y LA LEY

truth about immigrants and the law

Lecciones aprendidas ayudando a más de 50,000 inmigrantes en todo el país.

LA VERDAD SOBRE LOS INMIGRANTES Y LA LEY

truth about immigrants and the law

Lecciones aprendidas ayudando a más de 50,000 inmigrantes en todo el país.

Gracias por solicitar nuestro libro electrónico gratuito. Esperamos que le resulte útil. Es posible que aún tenga preguntas después de leer el libro, pero no se preocupe, siempre estamos aquí para ayudarlo. Solo llámanos al (888) 361-3349. Estaremos encantados de responder a sus preguntas.

Gracias,
Bert Diener

Descarga el libro aquí

THE TRUTH ABOUT IMMIGRANTS & THE LAW

truth about immigrants and the law

Lessons learned helping over 50,000 immigrants nationwide.

THE TRUTH ABOUT IMMIGRANTS & THE LAW

truth about immigrants and the law

Lessons learned helping over 50,000 immigrants nationwide.

THE TRUTH ABOUT IMMIGRANTS & THE LAW

truth about immigrants and the law

Lessons learned helping over 50,000 immigrants nationwide.

Thanks for requesting our free ebook. We hope that you find it helpful. You may still have questions after reading the book but don't worry, we are always here to help. Just give us a call at (888) 361-3349. We would be happy to answer your questions.

Thank you,
Bert Diener

Download the Book here

Let's Get You on Your Way to Legal Status!

To continue to our Immigration Solution Finder, please enter your name, email address, and telephone number. Then, click the accept and continue button.

Your privacy is important to us. We will keep the information you provide strictly confidential. We only use your information to determine if you may be eligible for immigration benefits in the United States. The information we provide should not be construed as legal advice and submission of this form does not create an attorney/client relationship.

Ask Us an Immigration Question or Request a Free Consultation

We are always happy to answer questions about immigration. You can use this form to ask us a question or request additional information but we would really like to get to know you. So, why not request a free consultation now?

Which Immigration concern can we help you with? I need to...

Ask Us a Personal Injury Question or

Request a Free Consultation

We are always happy to answer questions about Personal Injury. You can use this form to ask us a question or request additional information but we would really like to get to know you. So, why not request a free consultation now?

Which Personal Injury concern can we help you with? I need with...